Grammatical Problems

[mohsen57]

Which one of these sentence are true?

When did you arrive?
When did you arrived?

[Dianella]

Hi
I think none of them are correct because the verb "arrive" is always being used with verb "has" or "had" not did. I mean we use it as passive form.

Ofcourse I am not sure about this and waiting for someone to guide me through.

[Reza1969]

نوشته شده توسط mohsen57

Which one of these sentence are true?

When did you arrive?
When did you arrived?

Hi Mohsen

The first sentence is correct. Because when you want to make a question using simple past tense, you have to use the verb in its simple form inside the question.

Yours

Reza

[Dianella]

نوشته شده توسط Reza1969

Hi Mohsen

The first sentence is correct. Because when you want to make a question using simple past tense, you have to use the verb in its simple form inside the question.

Yours

Reza

Hi
I could be wrong but don't you think when we say "I arrived at somewhere or ect." we don't actually do an action? but describe a situation? which should be in some different way?
I don't know If I explain my meaning clear
please inform me about this cause now it's getting really interesting to me

[Reza1969]

نوشته شده توسط Dianella

Hi
I could be wrong but don't you think when we say "I arrived at somewhere or ect." we don't actually do an action? but describe a situation? which should be in some different way?
I don't know If I explain my meaning clear
please inform me about this cause now it's getting really interesting to me

Dear Dianella

It's as easy as ABC & I wonder why you get it the wrong way.

Look.The question is about the action of arriving & specially its time. When you reach or get to a place, you actually arrive there. Now if you wanna say the time of doing this action, sure you'll say:

I arrived in Tehran yesterday ( like : I saw this movie yesterday )

Now the question form of the above sentence:

When did you arrive in Tehran? ( like : When did you see this movie )

And more friendly : When did you arrive?

I hope it's all clear now

[Dianella]

Hi
thanks alot for clearing this up!
I don't know what's happening to me!
maybe it's an effect of stay late at night .
anyway thanks again and good night

[*NashenaS*]

نوشته شده توسط Reza1969

Hi Mohsen

The first sentence is correct. Because when you want to make a question using simple past tense, you have to use the verb in its simple form inside the question.

Yours

Reza

agreed

[nimo]

نوشته شده توسط mohsen57

Which one of these sentence are true?

When did you arrive?
When did you arrived?

hmmm just 1 more thing i need to pick on. we don't say true. the sentence is correct not true

[un4giv3n]

I think No.1!?!!

[mozhgan]

I m agree NO.1 too
really,dear dianella your signature is very beautiful and graceful.